Protests Grow Nationwide as Students Demand Divestment From Israel

Should the U.S. call for a ceasefire in Gaza?

  • 93.8k
    LeslieG
    Voted Yes
    10/19/2023

    Sure, sure arrest the peaceful demonstrators chanting but nothing was done to 1-6 to protestors defacing the Capitol, injuring people and threatening to kill politicians till weeks, months, years later.

    "...estimate of property damage due to the January 6 Capitol riot to $2.73 million, according to a Friday court filing in the case of a man who pleaded guilty to participating in the riot, which left windows broken, doors splintered and paintings stained with pepper spray and tear gas."

    "The final cost of the Capitol riot could exceed $30 million, taking into account the cost of mental health counseling for riot victims and other more indirect costs incurred by rioters, Brett Blanton, the architect of the Capitol, told Congress in February 2021."

    https://www.forbes.com/sites/zacharysmith/2022/04/08/capitol-riot-costs-go-up-government-estimates-273-million-in-property-damage/amp/

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12646451/amp/Pro-Palestinian-protesters-Capitol.html

  • 7,786
    DaveS
    Voted Maybe
    10/20/2023

    80% of any war are civilians deaths. Sad that Hamas uses it's people as shields and call for all Israel to die. The history between the Palestine and Israel, I wished it was be better, but it's not. So many lives lost because of what. If you only live to hate, you will never fine peace. Israel is justified in defending itself and so is Ukraine both are fighting for freedom and peace!

  • 372
    Robert
    10/20/2023

    No stopping till Hamas eliminated!

  • 362
    Debra
    Voted No
    last Wednesday

    Ancient conflict. Iran is on their doorstep and that is even a bigger issue.

    Although Israel is one of our allies we cannot dictate to them how to conduct their governmental affairs. We could however withold aid if we felt it was necessary. 

  • 7,920
    larubia
    Voted Yes
    11/02/2023

    In the quest to destroy Hamas (and deservedly so) Israel is killing Palestinian citizens, mostly women & children who have nothing to do with Hamas.  Hostages are still in the region, some are Americans. For the love of God, call a ceasefire! 

      

     Begin peace talks or find a strategic way to target Hamas & get rid of them once and for all (with little or no civilian casualties).

  • 7,786
    DaveS
    Voted Maybe
    10/20/2023

    So with all the people entering into pead agreement against Rico charges, will Judge Aileen Cannon end up being caught up in this as well ????? With the slow walking?

     

  • 767
    Jackie
    11/02/2023

    Pure and simple Israel is commiting war crimes.  Innocent citizens including children are being killed.  

  • 190
    Merry
    Voted No
    Yesterday at 5:53 PM

    too bad many of the protesters arent even students!!! 

    many have no clue what they are fighting for Palestinan rights? Jewish hate? Pure ability to protest!!! 

     

  • 33
    Alma
    Voted Yes
    Today at 4:18 AM

    We need to stop killing children in Gaza

  • 93.8k
    LeslieG
    Voted Yes
    Today at 6:08 PM

    Brown University and Northwestern University have successfully negotiated with students unlike other universities. If I was looking for a university to attend Brown and Northwestern Unuversity would be at top of my list for listening and engaging with students.

    Don't think other universities even tried to negotiate but instead opted to dictate out of fear for their jobs and the new McCarthyidm in Congress no doubt fueled by AIPAC campaign contributions.

    Brown wins the award for thinking outside the box to solve the problem.?Abd students are learning important skills in negotiating that they can use throughout their lives.

    "At Brown, a Rare Agreement Between Administrators and Protesters"

    "Brown students took down their tents on campus after the university in Rhode Island agreed to discuss their demands for divestment from support for the Israeli military."

    "Demonstrators agreed to dismantle their encampment at Brown, which had been removed by Tuesday evening, and university leaders said they would discuss, and later vote on, divesting funds from companies connected to the Israeli military campaign in Gaza."

    " The agreement lays out a series of steps for the months ahead:"

    "In May, five students will meet with five members of the Corporation of Brown University to argue for divesting funds from companies connected to the Israeli military."

    "In September, Brown’s advisory committee on resource management will be expected to advise the university on the same issue."

    "In October, the committee’s recommendation will be brought to the corporation for a vote."

    " Although the encampment will end, organizing to ensure that the Brown administration fulfills our calls to act on divestment will continue until the corporation vote in October,” the Brown Divest Coalition said in a statement on Tuesday."

    " A spokesman for Brown, Brian Clark, said that divestment was not as simple as some students might perceive, though. The university doesn’t invest its endowment directly, he said. Instead, it relies on “external specialist investment managers, all with the highest level of ethics and all whom we believe share the values of the Brown community.”

    “This feels like a real moment of realizing our collective power,” said Rafi Ash, a sophomore at Brown who participated in the protests. “This is something that demonstrates that the mobilization of the student body can force the university to listen.”

    "Administrators said in a statement that it would still hold disciplinary proceedings related to the encampment, which broke the university’s rules. Reports of harassment and discrimination will also be investigated, the statement said."

    "Administrators and student activists at Northwestern University struck a similar deal on Monday."

    https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/30/us/brown-divestment-deal.html

  • 5
    Susan
    Voted No
    Yesterday at 5:41 PM

    Calling Jews occupiers and colonialists is absurd, factually and historically. . Confusing Israel as an imperialist, colonial occupier is belied by the fact that Jews have always been, a significant proportion of the population, and in many decades, majority residents over the course of ancient and modern history. When they were not the majority, they were oppressed (raped, hanged, killed) for much of that time by their Muslim neighbors. 

     

    Jews were kicked out of Arab lands in numbers equal to the Arabs that left "Palestine" when the modern state of Israel was created in 1948. Arab countries, at the time, exhorted their Palestinian compatriots to leave "Israel" so they could be assured of killing all of the resident Jews without worrying about being caught in the violence. So they have just as much responsiblity to solve for "dispossed Palestinians" as the modern Israeli government does in not actively solving for a two state solution. 

     

    Current and prior Netanyahu administrations are to be blamed for many issues including fostering Hamas at the PLO's expense, delegitimizing and weakenng any non-jihadist Palestinian policiticans, effectively leaving no legitimate "other side" to negotiate a peaceful two state solution.  Hamas needs to leave/be kicked out of Gaza, the hostages freed and the Netanyahu government voted out of office. Then, we can have a ceasefire. 

     

    Calling for Palestine to be "freed from the river to the sea" is an ahistorically racist and anti-semitic chant by ignorant kids conflating collonialism with other world issues. 

     

     

  • 767
    Jackie
    Today at 12:52 PM

    Their prime minister is attempting to do to Gaza residents what the Nazi did to Jews.  I resent every cent of my tax dollars going to them.  I wish this money would go to aid for Gaza residents

  • 602
    Arnold
    Voted No
    Today at 10:16 AM

    Did Israel call for a ceasefire after 9 11 when the US bombed the hell out of Iraq and Afganistan? 

  • 1,017
    Deemax
    Voted Yes
    Today at 2:01 AM

    you don't stop protesting being heavy handed 

  • 3,320
    Steph
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 7:00 PM

    Yes.   And our Reps and Senators should sto[p accepting checks from AIPAC as well!

     

    Furthermore, Bibi is corrupt as they come and when he was reinstated into power there were protests all over Isarel because of his corruption and the fact that he was going to use all the right wing regime's tools to get away with it....and then suddenly HAMAS attacked Israel.  Hamas, whom Netanyahu had funded in the past.  And then suddenly, the attention of Isarel was diverted.

     

    I don't believe in coincidence when it comes to despots, just like I don't (and never did) believe in the Tooth Fairy.

  • 1,531
    Richard
    Voted No
    Yesterday at 9:30 PM

    Not our fight.  Hamas is ruthless and will not stop until Israel no longer exists. Palestine knows what side they are on, and it is not Israel. Plus Palestine and Hamas hates America. 

  • 3,890
    John
    Voted Maybe
    Yesterday at 7:13 PM

    It's not like Israel began this bloodbath. It was Hamas, that said Israel has taken it too far. These people need to learn to live together like the people in America. I am truly astounded to watch right wing Republican idiots like Taylor Green speaker Johnson freaking out over the student protest. While in fact, they could've cared less the Trump lead assault on the capital defaced in the American building, totally with them, quite literally pissing and crapping in the building aside from the fact that they smash windows and beat people have to death, but that's OK with the Republican party. I believe that the Republican party was torn down and reinvented into a party full of sanity. A lot of this crap in the world wouldn't happen. The students have a right to protest not to be violent. And the Republicans have a responsibility to see violence and protest for what it is and the riot at the capital was nothing other than assault on American freedom. Wake up Republicans look at what your leaders are doing. They're tearing this country down.

  • 718
    Dan
    Voted No
    Yesterday at 9:11 PM

    These college students are absolutely clueless! Hamas attacked Israel. Israel is justified in insuring Hamas is destroyed. The Pallestinians voted in Hamas as their governing body. Now, Hamas is shielding themselves by forcing civilians to remain in harm's way. This is pure evil. Again, Israel deserved to eliminate Hamas. College students are willing to protest for just about anything. If they put this much effort into a quality education, our nation would be much better off.

  • 2,937
    Arlys
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 6:25 PM

    Not just Gaza, but the entire world.  Nuculear testing should also be a "no-no".  Monitor climate change and sisemic activity and see what happens.  All this political "Game playing" needs to come to a halt and to hell with corporate profit margin as well as the power mad control freaks out there wanting to  show off their vanity.  We need strong leadership that will take care of it's own territory and not attempt to take over the world and the average people that live in it.

  • 2,412
    Martha
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 7:24 PM

    YES!!!  However, I believe that this has been called for over and over and the PM of  Israel has basically ignored that plea, with  a few exceptions.  I have said this many times and I'll say it again, the US can't fore the PM to do what we're urging it to do.  We cn, however suspend aide to try and force the PM to comply, but other than that we don't have much control of what the PM does or doesn't do, just like we don't have control of what Russia does or doesn't do.  With that said, I agree that Israel has gone too far in its response to the invasion of their country and are just as wrong in that over reaction as Hamas was in their initial attack.  Also, with that said I do stand with the student protest as long as those protest remain peaceful and do not include destruction of property or pose safety risk to individuals/groups of individuals.  The responses from the colleges seems a bit extreme when and if the protest are peaceful, but when those protest become violent/destructive then a strong arm approach becomes an option.  Now, this is all said as someone only seeing these events via news coverage and not up close and personal, so are the actions/reactions justified, I can't truely judge.

  • 423
    J
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 6:55 PM

    OF COURSE there should be a "cease-fire" in Gaza/Israel!
    And anyone that gives attention to REAL news...not the FAKE stuff KNOWS that Biden has been working of this and de-escalating mid-east conflict since first days in October!


    Two factions have CONTROL HAMAS and Netanyahu (with his extreme right wing). US with our Arab cooperators can only INFLUENCE the cease fire and negotiate for it.


    IF either the Palestinian protestors or Israeli/Jewish protesters REALLY wanted peace the would stop the campus conflict between themselves and dragging others in.


    But as I suspected there are non-student aggitators on-site with their own agendas: anti-semetic racism, political influence and "grand standing", disrupting civlitiy (yep there are such things as anarchists!) to promote/or slam a political party or person.


    Look at HOW MANY TIMES Biden has sent Blinken to the region, The Navy keeping the gulf open so aid ships can get in and deliver food and meds, Biden's limited ability to influence the Israeli criminal Netanyahu to delay and /or halt him from invading Rafah.
    Using the label "Genocide Joe" is completely unfounded. The US (Biden) did not start this and has been putting so much time into stopping this. HAMAS' stated purpose for being has been and is to "eliminate all jews" - THAT is "genocide". So, learn your terms AND HISTORY.


    FYI Netanyahu and his Generals are under investigation by the ICC and some warrants issued via the Hague...which Israel is NOT a member so seems unlikely they care about being charged and tried for and violation of conventions.


    The protesters I know locally are total IDIOTS puffing themselves up pretending they KNOW SOMETHING. They no crap. Not one of them went to college for Foreign affairs, political science, worked in the state department or defense.  There m ay be some disgrunted students in those colleges studying these topics...but if they are students they have NO EXPERIENCE that is partical or of value.

    I am your bane, because I grew up in the 60's, I learned history and acknowledge that both those things do not grant me EXPERIENCE and "special knowledge" that would only be available through government "channels".

    And DAILY, what I see of my Senators and Congressmen is that they may have access to some more information, doesn;t mean they have a gram of wisdom.

    Thank you for reading to the end...I have expression myself.

  • 1,396
    John
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 6:46 PM

    It's time for the US to take a stronger hand in the war in Gaza.  We should be withholding military aid to Israel immdiately.

  • 1,358
    Leslie
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 4:25 PM

    We need to stop the genocide being carried out by the Israeli government 

  • 1,064
    SigmaTriz
    Voted No
    Yesterday at 6:44 PM

    Did we call for a ceasefire during WW2?  Did we call for a ceasefire during the Iraq war?  Did we call for a ceasefire after 911?  If these ignorant kids don't get it then that's their problem.  Someone should explain to them they're wasting their parents monwy going to college because they absolutely learn nothing in school except being brainwashed.  This latest generation is suppose to be the future leaders of America?   That's the biggest saddest joke of the century.

  • 1,827
    George
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 5:42 PM

    We need to rescue those Palestinian civilians 

  • 180
    Theresa
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 4:38 PM

    This 'war' is a direct assault on human life. The only solution is peace.

  • 44
    Tara
    Voted Yes
    Yesterday at 4:14 PM

    Permanent ceasefire, return ALL hostages (both sides), end the seige, end the occupation, kick out illegal settlers, recognize as a state, right to self determination and a Free Palestine!