bill Progress
- Not enactedThe President has not signed this bill
- The house has not voted
- The senate has not voted
- senate Committees
Committee on the JudiciaryIntroducedJanuary 10th, 2017
The problem isn't immigration it's illegal immigration PERIOD!
Immigrants have always been the backbone of our economy. Unless we are willing to see food prices soar and video of thousands of families being rounded up and herded we can't let this happen. The children of these families are American and know the US as their only home.
City's like Los Angeles, San Francisco, etc. are vital economic engines that provide high-paying jobs and, in turn, collect plenty of revenue for Federal tax coffers. Local police, firefighters, etc. in these locales ABSOLUTELY MUST be trusted by ALL the people in their communities if they are to effectively solve and prevent crimes. The reason officials in these places won't "Turn in" so called "illegals" is that doing so would cause important crimes solving leads to "dry up" and create secretive, underground clusters of people living outside the law. As things stand now, law enforcement officials in these areas leverage EVERYONE in the community, regardless of their immigration status. In return, so called "illegals" can aid law enforcement without fear of recrimination. So everyone wins. (Oh... and YES these "illegals" buy goods & services, pay taxes, and generally contribute to the economies of these areas.)
It's essential that all people feel safe in our cities and that we never turn neighbors against each other. Sanctuary cities protect all people, the economy and peaceful coexistence. This nation was built on the contribution of immigrants, and we continue to benefit from their motivations to build a better life and stronger communities. Immigration is good for our economy and good for our cities. Immigrants must know that cities and law enforcement will not turn against them.
As someone living in a sanctuary city, working in the field of international education and immigration, I appreciate the amount of access a sanctuary city affords undocumented immigrants. These people deserve the right to attend school, work, and start lives in the US and by removing funding, undocumented immigrants would live in constant fear. I am proud to be from a sanctuary city. And I would hate to see that status or those protections change.
The current administrations stance on immigration is unconstitutional and un-American.
Sanctuary cities encourage illegal immigration and endanger public safety — they don't deserve federal funding. Plus, mandatory minimums will help deter more illegal immigration.
Local government must provide the resources, the police, and understands their own communities needs best. Attempts to punish cities for self-governance is the height of Big Government overreach.
Sanctuary cities treat undocumented people with the dignity they deserve as human beings. They should not be punished for doing so.
Not only should federal funding be withheld, legal action should also be taken. They are not only endangering the public, but are breaking the law.
A majority of these comments say that "immigrants" are the "backbone" of "American culture." All of that is 100% true, HOWEVER, this bill and the stricter immigration laws deal with ILLEGAL (Unlawful, criminal, etc..) IMMIGRANTS. If you do not want to comply with FEDERAL LAW, you lose your funding, simple as that.
"Give us your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to break free."
Under the supremacy clause of the United States constitution, federal law supersedes state law. A state (or city) not following federal immigration laws are in violation of this authority.
Sanctuary cities should not lose federal funding. These cities value the lives and contributions of the immigrant communities this new administration is targeting, and I support sanctuary cities' efforts to resist Trump's strong arm approach to the issue.
#AmericaFirst now!! I'm all for LEGAL immigration. It's the illegal immigrants that are the problem.
Please don't penalize Sanctuary Cities for protecting the most vulnerable among us. Thank you.
I am from a family of immigrants who came here legally. Everyone is welcome as long as they obey the law and that begins with the laws regarding legal immigration.
States should not be punished for showing basic human dignity to immigrants. No human being is illegal, no human being should be persecuted for trying to be safe, feed their families and find opportunities. This bill is a disgrace to the founding principles of the USA.