- Not enactedThe President has not signed this bill
- The senate has not voted
- The house has not voted
Committee on the JudiciaryImmigration and CitizenshipIntroducedJanuary 3rd, 2019
- house Committees
What is House Bill H.R. 48?
Cost of House Bill H.R. 48
In-Depth: Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee (D-TX) reintroduced this bill from the 115th Congress to prohibit the use of taxpayer money to build President Trump’s promised southern border wall. When she introduced this bill in the last Congress, Rep. Jackson Lee said:
“For too long, some in our country have been singularly obsessed with building a wall along our southern border. Unfortunately, the ringleader of these implacable individuals now occupies the highest office in our government. All of them, however, refuse to acknowledge that a border wall is highly ineffective and prohibitively expensive. So committed are they to their delusion, that the president is willing to shut down the government of the United States in pursuit of this folly. Realistic cost estimates of such a wall easily surpass tens of billions of dollars. This is an immense waste of taxpayer money that could be used to make the investments needed to make America better. This is why… I introduced H.R. 7332, the Protect American Taxpayers and Secure Border Act.’ If enacted, the law would prohibit the use of taxpayer dollars to construct the border wall. Moreover, it is a comprehensive piece of legislation that ensures that any wall that is build is paid for by Mexico; directs the Secretary of Homeland Security to make occur certain procedures that improve training of agents of the United States Custom and Border Patrol; increases the number of immigration judges; and, it directs the Secretary of DHS to take all such measures to ensure that refugees at the southern border are given humanitarian assistance. The modern reality of what is occurring at our southern border is shocking, and demands comprehensive legislation. This is why the Protect American Taxpayers and Secure Border Act is a necessary piece of legislation and I urge my colleagues to support it.”
Conservative news outlets have been highly critical of this legislation. Breitbart News criticized this bill when it was introduced in December 2018, saying that it “does nothing specific to secure the border.” Simiarly, RedState called this bill a “troll on the Trump administration”:
“If you were to create a tier system of insane Democrats, Democratic Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas would rank somewhere near the top, but her latest legislation uses one of Trump’s promises as a way to stop the wall from even being built in the first place, making us see a little method in her madness… Democrats, including its sponsors, haven’t really said much about the legislation, oddly enough, but it’s unlikely that the bill would actually get any traction. It’s highly likely that it was crafted as a way to troll the Trump administration.”
Of Note: The idea of making Mexico pay for the construction of a southern border wall was one of President Donald Trump’s major campaign promises during the 2016 election. According to The New York Times, Trump has repeated this promise “hundreds of times” and said it’d be “so easy” to fulfill. Trump has variously suggested compelling Mexico to make a one-time payment of $5-10 billion, deducting costs from Mexican foreign aid, impound remittance payments, increasing fees on temporary visas issued to Mexican CEOs and diplomats, increasing fees on border crossing cards, increasing fees on NAFTA worker visa from Mexico, and increasing fees at ports of entry from Mexico to the U.S.
However, as of January 2019, Trump has attempted to walk back this promise, saying that he never said Mexico would write a check:
“When — during the campaign, I would say, ‘Mexico is going to pay for it.’ Obviously, I never said this and I never meant they’re going to write out a check. I said, ‘They’re going to pay for it.’ They are. They are paying for it with the incredible deal we made, called the United States, Mexico, and Canada USMCA deal.”
In recent polling by Quinnipiac University, only 41 percent of Americans supported a southern border wall (down from 43 percent in the previous poll), while 55 percent opposed it. Declaring a national emergency to direct the wall’s construction — an idea that Trump has floated in recent weeks — has polled even more poorly than the wall alone. A Monmouth University poll found that 64 percent of Americans would disapprove of Trump using emergency power to direct military funds to build a border wall, while only 34 percent would approve of the move.
Summary by Lorelei Yang(Photo Credit: iStockphoto.com / Jorge Villalba)