Should the Presidential Budget Include the Total Amount Requested by Each Intel Agency? (H.R. 2735)
Do you support or oppose this bill?
What is H.R. 2735?
(Updated February 8, 2022)
This bill — the Intelligence Budget Transparency Act of 2019 — would require the president’s annual budget submission to Congress include the dollar amount requested for intelligence or intelligence-related activities by each intelligence agency. This would allow the public to see the total amount provided to each agency, but not line-item expenses.
Under current law, members of Congress can only see the total amount of the budget request unless they’re members of the intelligence committee or have otherwise been briefed on the matter.
Argument in favor
This bipartisan bill increases intelligence agencies’ accountability to U.S. taxpayers, who deserve to know at a high-level know where these tax dollars go. This would satisfy the transparency recommendations of the 9/11 Commission Report.
Argument opposed
Intelligence agencies’ activities are often covert and even revealing their top-line budgets without disclosing line-item details could signal America’s priorities to its foreign adversaries, hindering or compromising national security.
Impact
The general public; members of Congress; intelligence agencies; and the White House.
Cost of H.R. 2735
A CBO cost estimate is unavailable.
Additional Info
In-Depth: Rep. Peter Welch (D-VT) reintroduced this bill from the 115th Congress to require the president to disclose the topline annual budget request to Congress from each of the 16 federal agencies conducting intelligence activities. When he introduced this bill in the 115th Congress, he said:
“The biggest threat to the success of any federal program is a combination of unlimited money and non-existent oversight. That's the situation Congress has allowed to develop in the critical work of intelligence gathering. The top-line intelligence budgets for America's 16 intelligence agencies are unknown to the American taxpayer and largely unknown to the Members of Congress who represent them. It's led to dubious policies, wasted money and questionable effectiveness. Americans have a right to know how their tax dollars are being spent and that their national security interests are being well served.”
In a letter to his Congressional colleagues seeking cosponsors for this bill last Congress, Rep. Welch added that releasing topline budgets wouldn’t jeopardize national security:
“Ensuring America’s national security requires professional and competent intelligence agencies. But the urgency of the mission assigned to the 16 intelligence agencies should not shield them from budget accountability and transparency. In fact, the urgency of their mission makes the need for transparency even greater in order to assure Congress and the American people of the quality and effectiveness of their work… Simply disclosing the top-line spending at these agencies would not risk national security by identifying specific activities. It would, however, shed some much-needed light on the secrecy surrounding intelligence spending. The American people will be better served by knowing where they send their hard-earned tax dollars.”
Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR), who sponsored this bill in the 115th Congress, said:
“By operating secret programs funded by secret budgets, our national intelligence agencies enjoy a blank check as far as the American taxpayers are concerned. With little to no public oversight, it is even more important that Americans have at least some sense of whether they’re getting what they paid for. Requiring the disclosure of these budget requests is the first step in achieving greater accountability and transparency of these agencies.”
This bill has one cosponsor, Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-WI). In the 115th Congress, it had five bipartisan House cosponsors, including three Republicans and two Democrats, and didn’t receive a committee vote. The Senate version of this bill, sponsored by Sen. Ron Wyden (R-OR), had one cosponsor, Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY), in the 115th Congress and didn’t receive a committee vote.
Of Note: Currently, intelligence agency budgets are funded with a so-called “black budget” supplement that is debated and voted upon behind closed doors by congressional appropriators. Until recently, not even aggregate intelligence spending requests were disclosed.
The 9/11 Commission recommended the disclosure of top-line budget figures from each intelligence agency in order to increase transparency and accountability. In its report, the Commission wrote, “when even aggregate categorical numbers remain hidden, it is hard to judge priorities and foster accountability.”
This bill would require disclosure of funding requests from the following agencies: Air Force Intelligence, Army Intelligence, Central Intelligence Agency, Coast Guard Intelligence, Defense Intelligence Agency, Department of Energy, Department of Homeland Security, Department of State, Department of Treasury, Drug Enforcement Administration, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Marine Corps Intelligence, National Geospatial Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office, National Security Agency, and Navy Intelligence.
Media:
-
Sponsoring Rep. Peter Welch (D-VT) Dear Colleague Letter (115th Congress)
-
115th Congress Senate Sponsor Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) Press Release
-
Countable (Previous Version, 115th Congress)
Summary by Lorelei Yang
(Photo Credit: iStockphoto.com / undefined undefined)
The Latest
-
SCOTUS Hears Arguments of Abortion Pill Mifepristone CaseUpdated March 27, 2024, 12:30 p.m. EST On Tuesday, March 26, the Supreme Court heard arguments about the mifepristone case, read more... Women's Health
-
IT: ⛑️ It's American Red Cross Giving Day, and... How will you give back today?Welcome to Wednesday, March 27th, philanthropists and entrepreneurs... It's American Red Cross Giving Day - a time to ensure the read more...
-
Moscow Concert Hall, Russia’s Deadliest Attack in DecadesOn Friday, March 22, at least four men fired automatic weapons into a sold-out show at the Crocus City Hall auditorium in read more... Public Safety
-
Discover Gravvy — A New Way to Support What Matters MostDiscover Gravvy — A New Way to Support What Matters Most Are you ready to optimize your giving? read more...