bill Progress
- Not enactedThe President has not signed this bill
- The senate has not voted
- senate Committees
Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry - The house Passed January 12th, 2017Roll Call Vote 239 Yea / 182 Nay
- house Committees
Committee on AgricultureCommittee on Financial ServicesIntroducedJanuary 4th, 2017
Log in or create an account to see how your Reps voted!
Wall Street has not protected our economy in the past & it is foolish to think they ever will. Some oversight is necessary if only to justify the billions of dollars of taxpayer money that were used to bail out Wall Street. (The CFTC should welcome the reauthorization as it falls in line with this agency's whole stated purpose.)
Away with the bureaucracy. Part of the CFTC's purpose is "to avoid systemic risk, and to protect the market users and their funds." Well that's an impossible battle you've got on your hands. "Avoid systemic risk"? No such thing. Literally any steps the government can and does try to take to avoid systemic risk just make bigger market distortions. That's simply clear, obvious, historically-evident economic fact. And "protect market users and their funds"? Again, no such thing. You're just tasked with creating further market distortions that produce bigger bubbles and nastier crashes. Bubbles and crashes are a normal thing. People get excited about some area of the economy and it appreciates, then they take a step back and realize things aren't actually worth quite that much and the market corrects. That's a natural thing. What's unnatural is the bubble crashing the entire economy when it bursts rather than corrections in individual sectors. What's unnatural is not being able to bounce back quickly. These unnatural things are what you get when you try to artificially engineer markets and remove risk for people. There's no such thing as a risk-free investment. Anything you try to centrally plan to that effect just distorts the market and makes the long-run consequences worse. Agencies like this are fighting a losing battle, in fact an impossible one, and throwing more money at them is not the answer.
These kind of protections are essential for protecting middle class and lower class Americans from the billionaires. Personally, all the agriculture benefits are a home run for me as a midwesterner, even though I'm not involved in agriculture. Even as a democrat I can support this bill. Great bill!
Yes and more YES!! It has been proven time and time again when Wall Street is left unchecked it threatens the global economy.
Let's just eliminate the CFTC. Let the buyer beware. By the way, is the CFTC broken?
These "reforms" boil down to regulated entities no longer needing to preserve communications leading to commodity trades. In essence, this completely removes a fundamental component of the regulatory process, which, I'm sure, is the whole point.
We have seen what happens when stock, bond, and commodity trading goes unregulated. Do we seriously trust these guys to regulate themselves? I don't want another financial collapse like the last one they created.
This bill is necessary to support and protect the middle class from the greed and piracy of Wall Street
I would hope this passes metely for the fact that the companies still use paper for everything. Which can be tampered with. These companies should invest in encrypted software for most things yo not on stave off potential fraud but also to help the environment.
Government trying to be more open is like a wolf being vegetarian.
This bill reduces record keeping requirements in order to grow demand for the gambling-like derivatives market beyond financial institutions. Are we trying to force every company in our nation to play the market just to flood more profit into an unstable investment vehicle? This is how we develop national economic crises.
A select few are making millions fleecing the retirement accounts of the masses. It should be regulated, especially if they get government bailouts
I support this bill. The 99% needs all the protection it can get from the 1%.
An economic crisis brought by those working in the financial sector cannot be allowed to happen again. They need to be accountable for their dealings and not expected to be saved by taxpayers, the very victims of their shenanigans.
Wall Street has proven it needs to be regulated. End of story.
If you blindly trust people makimg large sums of money to do the right things in the pursuit of those large sums of money all the time your naive.
The CFTC’s administration would be shaken up by making its division directors answerable to the entire Commission. A new Office of the Chief Economist would be established to report economic data and analysis to the entire Commission. “No-Action” letters that the CFTC issues would be subject to additional scrutiny, as they had been outside of the traditional oversight process. Proposed new rules would also be subject to a cost-benefit analysis before their implementation.
Derivatives are facing a market failure and need government direction to keep them from catastrophe.