Like Countable?

Install the App
TRY NOW

house Bill H.R. 1404

Should Vladimir Putin’s Net Worth Be Investigated by the U.S. Gov’t?

Argument in favor

An accurate accounting of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s net worth, along with its sources, would go a long way towards fighting global corruption and improving U.S. national security through an improved understanding of how Putin uses money to stay in power.

Melissa's Opinion
···
03/12/2019
Putin is reportedly worth $200 billion. That kind of wealth is literally capable of running the world. (Especially since no one is monitoring on how that money is spent.) He is buying and selling politicians and governments worldwide. Wreaking havoc every step of the way. For the sanctity of America, anything that can stem the damage -- and lead to uncovering him for the nemesis that he is (he has vowed to destroy the U.S. for decades) -- is worth the effort.
Like (15)
Follow
Share
Lionman's Opinion
···
03/12/2019
Seems like this should be part of an Intelligence Dossier.
Like (14)
Follow
Share
KansasTamale's Opinion
···
03/12/2019
Knowing Russian President Vladimir Putin’s net worth, along with its sources, and expenditures would help in fighting global corruption and improving U.S. National Security , as well as, uncover Americans who either took payments or laundered money for Putin. That would lead to charges & hopefully jail for those treasonous people.
Like (11)
Follow
Share

Argument opposed

Singling Putin out will only antagonize the Kremlin, straining an already frosty U.S.-Russia relationship. It’d also be incredibly difficult — if not impossible — to get an accurate picture of Putin’s finances, given the layers of proxy owners and shell corporations to work through.

Victoria's Opinion
···
03/12/2019
It's none of the USA's business! My God, are people really this stupid?
Like (58)
Follow
Share
Trent's Opinion
···
03/12/2019
Why? Can we audit him? He was in the panama papers. I’m pretty sure he hides his money. We aren’t the worlds police. I thought this was actually a joke. We can’t get our own presidents tax returns but we want to audit the most powerful man in the world. Got it.
Like (37)
Follow
Share
Bernadine's Opinion
···
03/12/2019
Absolutely not. We already have our noses in too many places.
Like (31)
Follow
Share

bill Progress


  • Not enacted
    The President has not signed this bill
  • The senate has not voted
      senate Committees
      Select Committee on Intelligence
  • The house has not voted
    IntroducedFebruary 27th, 2019

What is House Bill H.R. 1404?

This bill — the Vladimir Putin Transparency Act — would seek to expose Russian President Vladimir Putin’s corruption by arriving at a better assessment of his ill-gotten wealth. To this end, this bill would direct the Director of National Intelligence, in coordination with the Treasury Secretary and the Secretary of State, to put together an assessment of Putin’s and Putin’s family members’ net worths and financial assets, both legitimate and illegitimate.

The report would be required to contain information on:

  • Putin’s and his family members’ estimated net worths;
  • A description of their legitimately and illegitimately obtained assets, including all real, personal, and intellectual property, bank or investment or similar accounts, and any other financial or business interests or holdings, including those outside Russia;
  • The details of legitimately and illegitimately obtained assets (including real, personal, and intellectual property, bank or investment or similar accounts, and any other financial or business interests or holdings, including those outside Russia) that are owned or controlled by, accessible to, or otherwise maintained for Putin’s benefit, including their nature, location, manner of acquisition, value, and publicly named owner (if other than Vladimir Putin);
  • The methods used by Putin, or others at at his direction with his knowledge, or for his benefit, to conceal Putin’s interest in his accounts, holdings, or other assets — including the establishment of “front” or shell companies and the use of intermediaries; and
  • An identification of the most significant senior Russian political figures, oligarchs, and any other persons who may have engaged in activities intended to conceal Putin’s true financial condition.

The report would be due to the appropriate congressional committees within 180 days from the passage of this bill. The report could be submitted in one of two forms: 1) unclassified form to the extent consistent with the protection of intelligence sources and methods, potentially with a classified annex, or 2) simultaneously as both an unclassified and a classified version.

“Appropriate congressional committees” refers to House and Senate committees with jurisdiction over matters related to finance, foreign affairs, and intelligence.

Impact

Russia; Congress; Director of National Intelligence; Secretary of State; Treasury Secretary; Vladimir Putin’s family members; and Vladimir Putin.

Cost of House Bill H.R. 1404

A CBO cost estimate is unavailable.

More Information

In-DepthRep. Val Demings (D-FL) introduced this bill to direct the U.S. intelligence community and federal government to create and submit to Congress a report on all of Putin’s financial holdings:

“Russia and Putin have been allowed free reign by this administration and as a result our democracy is still at risk. The best way to assail the power of Putin and his enablers is to go after the illegal and secret financial streams that fund their operations. It’s time to fight back and protect our democracy. Twenty-six Russians and three Russian companies have already been indicted for interfering with the 2016 election, but this administration has done little to prevent future attacks. Russia has continued its campaigns of disinformation, propaganda, and political and military pressure against U.S. allies and interests.”

Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY), an original cosponsor of this bill, adds that this bill treats Putin and his allies appropriately, as “nefarious political actors”:

“Putin and his political allies seek to weaken democracies worldwide by consolidating their political control through unethical means. I am proud to cosponsor this bill which aims to identify Putin and his allies for who they are: nefarious political actors undermining democracies.”

Many experts agree that a more accurate understanding of Putin’s wealth could help crack down on cross-border corruption and give the U.S. more leverage against Russia. Experts argue that Putin could be the wealthiest man in the world, and many of his assets have been stolen from the Russian state and handed over to a network of allies and oligarchs.

Brian O’Toole, an expert in economic sanctions at the Atlantic Council, added that a public accounting of Putin’s vast wealth and its corrupt origins could hurt him domestically:

“Even though a public report is unlikely to contain great detail on Putin’s illicit wealth, highlighting his family’s vast holdings and placing an estimate on what he has plundered from the Russian state hits at an area of rare weakness—domestic corruption, for a leader who consistently has enjoyed high approval ratings. Beyond that, hitting out at Putin’s wealth and involving his family in the analysis would be certain to annoy him, which is not an insubstantial outcome.”

John Wonderlich, executive director of the Sunlight Foundation, an organization that advocates for transparency and open government, notes that it’s uncommon for the government to pass a bill to collect this type of information, but this approach may be needed in Putin’s case:

“I think it would be useful to have an overall more reliable estimate of Putin’s personal financial wealth because it would be helpful to have a better sense of how his influence is functioning, not just in that region of the world, but all over the world, because that’s the way that global wealth functions. I’m not sure this bill is the right way to go about it. It’s an unusual approach to require the DNI to put together an estimate for a specific foreign leader. Then again, Putin is not just another foreign leader either. It’s an unusual approach to an unusual situation.”

Kremlin spokesman Dmitriy Peskov dismissed this bill as “just some more Russophobic fuss,” telling reporters in Moscow:

“It [this bill] can hardly be taken seriously. Most likely it’s just some more Russophobic fuss. We’ve long learned to take that with irony.”

Alexander Cooley, a Eurasia expert at Columbia University’s Harriman Institute, notes that it’s unsurprising that Russian officials would criticize this bill, and suggests that rather than singling Russia out, it may be better to combat global kleptocracy regardless of where it occurs:

"Institutional efforts to publicize details of Vladimir Putin's personal wealth are likely to be viewed by Moscow as yet another example of the U.S. singling out Russia, and its leadership, for exceptional opprobrium and would likely precipitate some sort of retaliation. It would make more sense, for those committed to the causes of transparency and global anti-kleptocracy, to lay out a set of guiding principles under which information about the overseas money and reputation laundering of political elites worldwide can be compiled and publicized."

Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY) is currently this bill’s only cosponsor.

This isn’t the first time Reps. Demings and Stefanik have teamed up to introduce legislation countering Russian influence. In the 115th Congress, the duo, along with Rep. Ted Lieu (D-CA), introduced the Defend Against Russian Disinformation and Aggression Act, which sought to strengthen federal cybersecurity, support intelligence-gathering, and enhance NATO military activities. That bill never received a committee vote.

Last Congress, a bipartisan group of Senators consisting of Sens. Lindsey Graham (R-SC), Cory Gardner (R-CO), John McCain (R-AZ), Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Bob Menendez (D-NJ), and Ben Cardin (D-MD), introduced the Defending American Security from Kremlin Aggression Act of 2018, which would have called for strengthened sanctions on Russia and specifically on “political figures, oligarchs, and family members and other persons that facilitate illicit and corrupt activities, directly or indirectly, on behalf of Vladimir Putin” and required a report on Putin’s net worth and assets. The bill never received a committee vote.


Of NoteAccording to the Washington Post, the Russian government’s official public reports show Putin’s average income from 2011-2016 at approximately $112,000. The Kremlin also reports that he lives in a small apartment. However, outside experts have alleged that his true net worth is in the billions, thanks to extensive corruption and a connection to money laundering and other activities. In 2012, former Russian government adviser Stanislav Belkovsky estimated that Putin’s fortune was worth $70 billion. In 2017, hedge fund manager Bill Browder, the CEO of Hermitage Capital Management and a noted critic of Putin who pushed for the Magnitsky Act’s passage in 2012, leading to U.S. sanctions against Russian oligarchs, told the Senate Judiciary Committee he believe Putin’s net worth is more like $200 billion (which would propel Putin far past Amazon founder and current richest man in the world Jeff Bezos, whom Forbes estimates is worth $150.2 billion). In his Senate testimony, Browder claimed:

“I believe he [Putin] is worth $200 billion. The purpose of the Putin regime has been to commit terrible crimes in order to get that money, and he doesn't want to lose that money by having it frozen. So he is personally at risk of the Magnitsky Act."

Browder also added that Putin’s hidden fortune, if he has indeed accumulated one, would be based on an informal idea of ownership, and compared the system to the mafia:

“There isn't going to be a shares certificate with Putin's name on it, or a bank account linked to him. The way mafia syndicates work is that you have a godfather who does favors for his underlings. In return, at some point in the future, his underlings return the favor... it makes more sense to think about it like that."

Browder points to Russia’s missing money as evidence that Putin has stashed money away:

"After 14 years in power of Russia, and the amount of money that the country has made, and the amount of money that hasn't been spent on schools and roads and hospitals and so on, all that money is in property, bank--Swiss bank accounts--shares, hedge funds, managed for Putin and his cronies.”

Ex-Russian officials have also accused Putin of greater wealth and influence than is officially reported. In 2007, ex-Kremlin official Stanislav Belkovsky claimed that Putin had $40 billion hidden in Switzerland and Liechtenstein — if true, that’d have made him the world’s fourth-wealthiest person at the time. Belkovsy also accused Putin of secretly controlling 37 percent of Surgutneftegaz and 4.5 percent of Gazprom, two giant Russian oil companies, as well as “at least 75 percent” of Swiss oil trader Gunvor. Belkovsy added, “I suspect there are some businesses I know nothing about.” However, Gunvor refuted Belkovsy’s claims, saying that “President Putin does not and never has had any ownership, beneficial or otherwise in Gunvor. He is not a beneficiary of Gunvor or its activities."

Similarly, exiled Russian banker Sergei Pugachev, once nicknamed “Putin’s banker,” told the Guardian, “Everything that belongs to the territory of the Russian Federation Putin considers to be his.” Pugachev claimed that “any attempt to calculate [Putin’s net worth] won’t succeed. He’s the richest person in the world until he leaves power.”

Additionally, the Kremlin’s numbers and reporting don’t match up with most accounts of Putin’s lifestyle, including the so-called “secret palace,” which was reportedly built using illegal state funds at the cost of $1 billion. The residence has a private theater and landing pad with room for three helicopters. In 2012, opposition leader and Putin critic Boris Nemtsov produced a dossier claiming that Putin owned 58 different types of aircraft, including one with an $11 million cabin fitted out by jewelers and a toilet that cost close to $100,000, as well as four yachts, each costing thousands of dollars to maintain. Nemtsov’s dossier also claimed that Putin owned 11 watches, worth a combined $687,000. Nemstov was assassinated in 2015.

In 2015, the Panama Papers suggested that Putin has likely used proxies to conceal his actual wealth. While the Papers didn’t include any files directly pertaining to Putin, they did reveal that his friends had earned millions from deals that seemingly couldn’t have been secured without his patronage. However, Putin and the Kremlin deny that he’s used his role to enrich himself and his friends. In response to the Panama Papers, Putin wrote:

“I am the wealthiest man, not just in Europe but in the whole world: I collect emotions. I am wealthy in that the people of Russia have twice entrusted me with the leadership of a great nation such as Russia. I believe that is my greatest wealth."


Media:

Summary by Lorelei Yang

(Photo Credit: iStockphoto.com / dicus63)

AKA

Vladimir Putin Transparency Act

Official Title

To strengthen the United States response to Russian interference by providing transparency on the corruption of Russian President Vladimir Putin.

    Follow the money.
    Like (24)
    Follow
    Share
    It's none of the USA's business! My God, are people really this stupid?
    Like (58)
    Follow
    Share
    Why? Can we audit him? He was in the panama papers. I’m pretty sure he hides his money. We aren’t the worlds police. I thought this was actually a joke. We can’t get our own presidents tax returns but we want to audit the most powerful man in the world. Got it.
    Like (37)
    Follow
    Share
    Absolutely not. We already have our noses in too many places.
    Like (31)
    Follow
    Share
    I think the USA needs to stop focusing so much on everyone else, and focus more on their own internal corruption and problems.
    Like (24)
    Follow
    Share
    More demoncratic stupidity.
    Like (18)
    Follow
    Share
    We already know he is corrupt but it’s not our responsibility to investigate him. We only cause more trouble for ourselves when we interfere in the affairs of other countries.
    Like (17)
    Follow
    Share
    Putin is reportedly worth $200 billion. That kind of wealth is literally capable of running the world. (Especially since no one is monitoring on how that money is spent.) He is buying and selling politicians and governments worldwide. Wreaking havoc every step of the way. For the sanctity of America, anything that can stem the damage -- and lead to uncovering him for the nemesis that he is (he has vowed to destroy the U.S. for decades) -- is worth the effort.
    Like (15)
    Follow
    Share
    Seems like this should be part of an Intelligence Dossier.
    Like (14)
    Follow
    Share
    Knowing Russian President Vladimir Putin’s net worth, along with its sources, and expenditures would help in fighting global corruption and improving U.S. National Security , as well as, uncover Americans who either took payments or laundered money for Putin. That would lead to charges & hopefully jail for those treasonous people.
    Like (11)
    Follow
    Share
    Why? Seriously, what good will this number do us? How would we even get a accurate number? Will it change anything about how the USA/Russia relations work? No? Then why?
    Like (11)
    Follow
    Share
    Leave Putin to the Russians. The connection between the puppeteer and the puppet will be found by investigating #45’s money, both past and present. The U.S. should first investigate #45, his family and more importantly, all the business ventures, (active and failed), that bear his name. Answers regarding #45’s corruptness, greed and thievery will be answered if investigators follow his money trail. Key to the investigation will be #45’s Income Tax reports for at least the last (10) yrs. Investigating #45’s money will shed light on the TRUTH regarding lies, bribes, pay-offs and other illegal actions.
    Like (11)
    Follow
    Share
    With power comes responsibility. Those responsibilities are to the people you serve. Transparency is part of that equation.
    Like (10)
    Follow
    Share
    H.R. 1404 AKA- To strengthen the United States response to Russian interference by providing transparency on the corruption of Russian President Vladimir Putin. I can’t recommend the passage of the House bill H.R.1404 which was sponsored by Rep. Demings, Val Butler [D-FL-10] (Introduced 02/27/2019)and like her mentor (Speaker Pelosi)apparently won’t let us know what is in the bill until its passed. I may be a conspiracy theorist who,believes that our Democratic members of Congress, particularly the U.S. House following their regaining control of the HOUSE. It’s beginning to be apparent that they, the opposition Progressive Liberal Socialist Leaning Democrats are going to lean towards their Investigation agendas rather than legislating as their constituents elected them to do. So until I see what’s in the bill, I’d be suspicious 😒 of its contents and if, as I’d suspect, there is going to be another attempt at attacking President Trump by the Pelosi led House. SneakyPete......... 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻. 3*10*19..........
    Like (9)
    Follow
    Share
    Considering his interest in elections around the world and recent military build up in the region, i fully believe we should be looking into Putin’s wealth and his current interests. If the US has been a party to hiding any of Putin’s money the American people need to know. We need to send a strong signal there are consequences to meddling in elections and military aggression while stealing a counties wealth for ones own enrichment.
    Like (8)
    Follow
    Share
    We need a bill to do this??? What does the CIA do?? Are House Reps, second guessing our intelligence taskers?? They can't legislate let alone play spy. Out of the playground and back to work.
    Like (8)
    Follow
    Share
    Donald Trump and his net worth should be investigated. Trump is the epitome of corruption. That’s plain as day. It’s just that some just don’t care. Shame on you congress. We will all have to pay the consequences of this disaster in the White House.
    Like (6)
    Follow
    Share
    And Trump's and Bernie Sander's. No more concealed financial conflicts of interest
    Like (6)
    Follow
    Share
    YES! HE HAS STOLEN EVERYTHING FROM THE PEOPLE OF RUSSIA! HE IS DESPICABLE AS IS TRUMP
    Like (5)
    Follow
    Share
    Investigate to find all the money laundering and corruption and criminal scams.
    Like (5)
    Follow
    Share
    MORE