by Countable | Updated on 3.14.18
A federal appeals court ruled on Tuesday that most of Texas’ ban on so-called "sanctuary cities" can take effect while legal proceedings advance in court.
The law-in-question, Senate Bill 4, allows Texas police officers to ask people their immigration status during routine stops and requires local law enforcement to cooperate with federal immigration officials.
The appeals panel halted one provision of the law: a clause barring local officials from "adopting, enforcing, or endorsing" policies that limit the enforcement of immigration laws.
Gov. Greg Abbott (R) took to twitter to praise the ruling:
BREAKNG: Texas Ban on Sanctuary City Policies upheld by Federal Court of Appeals. Allegations of discrimination were rejected. Law is in effect.— Greg Abbott (@GregAbbott_TX) March 13, 2018
"The court made clear that we remain free to challenge the manner in which the law is implemented, so we will be monitoring the situation on the ground closely," Lee Gelernt, deputy director of the ACLU’s Immigrants’ Rights Project, told the Texas Tribune.
Do you support "sanctuary cities" and “sanctuary states”? Are undocumented immigrants a state or federal issue? Hit Take Action and tell your reps, then share your thoughts below.
(Photo Credit: Kroach / iStock)
Written by Countable
I am a Texas resident. I support the concept of sanctuary cities. The horrendous persecution of people of color especially those of Hispanic descent is not justified in my eyes. The news is filled with reports of American residents of decades long duration who are living exemplary lives being rounded up and deported. For what reason? Should brown people have to carry their citizenship papers? Many many Americans do not support what is being done to immigrants and thus sanctuary cities have arisen. One day hopefully sanity will return to the USA.
Yes I support sanctuaries, whether city, County or State. ICE is too similar to the Gestapo in 1930s Germany. Local policing and federal policing aren’t the same. Local police need the resources to handle criminals and if trust isn’t there, it poses serious problems. Also, aren’t Republicans/Conservatives into State’s rights?
Whenever one group of people is scapegoated and brute force is used to round them up, while assuring the people who haven’t been rounded up today that all is well, we have all the hallmarks of a fascist dictatorship. With daily assaults on balance of powers, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and with propaganda against people of color, we have hallmarks of a fascist dictatorship. White privilege promotes not caring about all others. My American born Japanese ethnicity husband was targeted while his undocumented Scottish friend never was. Native Americans are targeted while “white“ terrorists are supported. Sanctuary cities fight racist xenophobia. Sanctuary cities fight fascism. Sanctuary cities fight military dictatorships.
It’s surprising how many Americans have been frightened by this Administration. If it cannot keep Americans safe without walls, making police officers Immigrant narcs, extreme vetting at our airports, ICE agents grabbing people off of our streets, then they are weak indeed.
How is it racist to uphold federal law? That is just absurd. Protecting illegal immigrants from deportation is illegal. This law, hopefully, sets a precedent for other states and cities that ignore federal law and set up sanctuary states and cities. No one gets to pick and choose which laws they want to follow and not expect repercussions. It’s about time that courts recognize that states need to follow federal laws. Thank you, Texas!
Sounds great! That is the job of police! If they stop me I have no problem answering that! Get them out of here if they are here illegally!
Going after real criminals and gang members is one thing. Going after people who are stable, tax payers and business owners, children, parents is just wrong. I bet, unless the ICE agents are Native Americans their history is as an immigrant. We are all immigrants and our country has thrived on their work ethics, integration into our society and they take jobs many Americans are NOT flocking to take. I do not support this ruling. Sad. Pathetic.
This is great news! Sanctuary Cities are harboring criminals. Nothing about discrimination or racism! That is what Liberals always fall back on to advance their agenda!
Yes finally some Federal judges who interpret law instead of being legislative judges which isn’t their job. I pray we have more of these victories. #MAGA
It’s good to see that the court recognizes the rule of law.
I support sanctuary cities. Stop ripping families apart.We are all immigrants, accept the Native Americans. This is not just a White mans country.
HEIL TRUMP!!! HE'LL BE IN HIS ELEMENT WHEN EVERYONE STANDS WITH A STRAIGHT ARM SALUTE IN HIS DAMN PARADE..PROTECT OUR CITIZENS AND IMPEACH THE MORON IN CHARGE!
Welcome to the American Reich. Papers please. When did we become this?
I absolutely do not support “ sanctuary cities and states “ You do not get to ignore federal law. If you are here illegally you have already broken federal law. If you are a citizen and don’t like the idea that the Country has boarders and laws that need to be respected and obeyed... you have a decision to make.
As long as it only pertains to folks who are felons and committed a crime. Those who are working jobs and free of criminal actions leave them alone. They are only seeking a better life for themselves and their families.
Texas would support the idea of one sanctuary city,,, San Francisco! You want em? You can have all the illegals you want. Here in Texas we’ll welcome the legal immigrant but will never support the idea of an illegal alien. Our problem is not the nationality, it’s the legality. God Bless Texas
Steps need to be taken to dismantle ICE! They are nothing more than government funded bounty hunters. Domestic terrorism should not be legal in our country, and neither should ICE!
Bring these Liberal Minded Cities to their Knees and States too if they don’t want to Obey our Laws of the Land!! Our Nation is Founded on Laws Handed Down to Us and for the ones who elect to not follow them cut them Off of Any Federal Funding Now. Then we will see how they Like It!!
Texas has legalized ‘pulling em over’ if they are brown. People have been detained while wearing yarmulkes in Germany and hoodies in the US. How did brown become our 21st century dog whistle for bigotry? Make America Hate Again...build a wall...be afraid. We are a hot mess.
The liberal narrative that innocent people who have lived exceptional lives in the US for years are being rounded up and deported is absolutely BS. They are not innocent since they are illegally in the US which means they are criminals. I personally don’t care what someone else thinks of their work ethics or behavior while being in the US. What I do care about is the ‘Rule of Law’ which is not based upon how some liberal feels but hard legal facts. If you enter the US illegally - you are a criminal and should be arrested and then deported no matter how long it takes to find you. If you want to come to the US then get in line behind the law abiding immigrants and wait your turn.