Know a Nominee: Judge Peter Phipps to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals
Do you support or oppose Phipps' nomination?
by Countable | 7.16.19
Updated - 7/16/19: The Senate confirmed Judge Peter Phipps to the Third Circuit on a 56-40 vote that saw the same three Democrats who voted in favor of cloture join all Republicans in voting to confirm.
Updated - 7/15/19: The Senate advanced the nomination of Judge Peter Phipps to the Third Circuit on a 53-40 cloture vote, which saw Democratic Sens. Doug Jones (AL), Joe Manchin (WV), and Kyrsten Sinema (AZ) join all Republicans in voting in favor. A confirmation vote is expected Tuesday.
The Senate is expected to consider the nomination of Judge Peter J. Phipps to be U.S. Circuit Judge for the Third Circuit Court of Appeals this week beginning with a procedural vote on Monday. Here’s what you need to know about the nominee:
Who is he?
- Peter J. Phipps, 46, is a U.S. District Court Judge for the Western District of Pennsylvania. He was confirmed to the bench in October 2018 following a unanimous voice vote on the Senate floor, which followed a similar voice vote in the Judiciary Committee.
- Prior to serving as a federal juge, Phipps began his career in civil litigation at the law firm Jones Day before spending 14 years working in the Dept. of Justice’s Civil Division as senior trial counsel.
- Before joining Jones Day, Phipps served as a law clerk for Judge R. Guy Cole Jr. of the U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals.
- Phipps earned his undergraduate degree with honors from the University of Dayton and his law degree with honors from Stanford Law School, where he was the managing editor of the Stanford Law & Policy Review.
What’s the outlook for his confirmation?
- The Senate Judiciary Committee advanced Judge Phipps’ circuit court nomination on a party-line 12-10 vote.
- One of Phipps’ home state senators, Sen. Bob Casey (D-PA) declined to return a “blue slip” to signal his support for the nomination, citing “significant concerns over Judge Phipps’ judicial and constitutional philosophy” and his brief tenure on the bench. However, the lack of a returned blue slip no longer gives home state senators the power to stop a nomination.
- Judge Phipps’ other home state senator, Sen. Pat Toomey (R-PA), said Phipps would make “an outstanding addition to the Third Circuit” and that he has the “experience, intellect and integrity to be a superb circuit court judge.”
- A substantial majority of the American Bar Association’s judicial nomination rating board gave Judge Phipps’ a rating of “well qualified” while a minority of the panel gave him a rating of “qualified” to serve on the Third Circuit Court of Appeals.
What does it mean for the Third Circuit?
- Judge Phipps’ confirmation would fill a position on the Third Circuit Court of Appeals that became vacant when Judge Thomas I. Vanaskie (a Barack Obama appointee) assumed senior status in November 2018. Vanaskie’s duty station was in Scranton, Pennsylvania.
- The Third Circuit has 14 active judgeships. Of the judges on the bench, two were appointed by Bill Clinton, four by George W. Bush, four by Barack Obama, and three by Donald Trump. Phipps’ confirmation would file the lone vacancy.
— Eric Revell
(Photo Credit: iStock / imaginima)
Would You Support Impeaching Trump Over His Ukraine Call?What’s the story? A cache of Democrats is calling for the House to begin impeachment proceedings against President Donald Trump
by Countable | 9.23.19
The DC: Trump discussed Biden with Ukraine, and... 🧾 Should presidential candidates have to release their tax returns to be on the ballot?Welcome to Monday, September 23rd, uppers and downers...President Donald Trump confirmed Sunday that he discussed former Vice
by Countable | 9.23.19
Committee Watch: Assault Weapons, the Border Crisis, and the Intel Community Whistleblower ComplaintBefore bills and nominations are brought up for a passage vote in Congress, they typically have to be considered and approved by
by Countable | 9.22.19