by Countable | 9.7.17
A ballot initiative in Massachusetts would require presidential candidates to publicly release six years of tax returns in order to appear on the state’s ballot.
The initiative was certified on Wednesday, meaning backers can now begin collecting signatures for the measure to appear on an upcoming ballot.
At the same time, Massachusetts state lawmakers held a hearing on a bill that would also require presidential candidates to release their tax returns to get on the state ballot. Candidates for vice president would have the same requirement.
"This bill is not about Donald Trump. It’s because of Donald Trump."
The quote comes from William Galvin, the Democratic secretary of state, during testimony about the bill. Galvin is referring to Trump breaking decades of tradition by refusing to release his tax returns during the 2016 presidential race.
Senator Michael Barrett, the bill’s Democratic sponsor, acknowledged that laws requiring a release of tax records could be subject to lawsuits. As Reuters explained, "The U.S. Constitution sets out qualifications to become president, and critics could argue the state’s law would unconstitutionally do the same."
Galvin, however, testified that these laws could survive a legal challenge as states have a right to set conditions to get on their ballots.
"I don't think there's any doubt that the states have the right to proscribe conditions for access to the ballot. We do that all the time," Galvin said, noting that the state also requires Congressional candidates to collect a certain number of signatures to get on the ballot. "Adding this additional qualification of disclosure is just one more question of access to the ballot."
Similar bills are pending in 24 states. In 2016, New Jersey lawmakers passed legislation requiring presidential candidates to disclose their tax returns, but it was vetoed by Gov. Chris Christie.
The Constitution says there are only three requirements to be elected president: The Commander in Chief must be a "natural born citizen," at least 35 years old and a resident within the U.S. for 14 years. However, states do have the right to create conditions to get on the ballot. Should releasing tax returns be one of them? Hit the Take Action button, tell your state reps, then comment below.
(Photo Credit: @realDonaldTrump via Twitter)
Written by Countable
Well I think we learned this lesson.We should expect and require all candidates as well as Congressional appointments to clear a full background and financial vetting PRIOR to any appointment. This is standard practice for all My Law Enforcement Jobs as well as my wife's Federal Job . No one should be appointed or hired without this check .
We should have a certified health report from Walter reed hospital, a mental evaluation from same, financial report concerning holdings and divestment plan if elected and tax returns and a criminal background check. Failure to comply means no nomination by any party.
A good start, now all 50 states need to follow suit.
Of course it should be law- It would immediately be known who and what influencers the candidates are answering to.
Not only should they release six years of tax returns (prefer 10 years, but six will do), they must commit to a divestment plan or blind trust, and submit to a complete medical and mental health evaluation administered by Walter Reed National Military Medical Center (details of which should not be made public, just a general assessment) prior to entering the primaries.
Transparency in elections should be the standard process. Candidates must expect to be vetted. Voters need detailed information to select qualified officials with integrity, humility, and honesty.
Yes, there should be transparency not only for candidates, but for any presidential appointees too.
All politicians should have to comply with common employment processes. Drug tests, criminal history, physical, and credit check.
It's sad that it must come to regulation since Presidents have willingly made their tax returns available for the past forty years, but Trump hiding his returns requires one more change to norms. There is little normal about this administration.
Total transparency must be required. Financial, business investments, criminal past, medical exam by a panel, psychiatric exam by a panel, all these will be necessary for all cabinet level positions and higher in the future. What has happened with this administration must never happen again.
Yes I want to see the law like this will require every federal, state, county, & city political candidates to show their tax returns because they get pay from the taxpayers. It will be more fair to every levels of political candidates
Love it ❤️
It's about time.
I think we should require all presidential candidates to release at least 6 years of tax returns to appear on the ballot.
Because of trump, we see that there should be many requirements to run for the office of President of America. Showing tax returns is definitely one of them!!!
I support having to turn over tax returns as a criteria for running for office. Politicians should be vetted for illegal or unethical behavior before running for office.
I'd like to see Washington state be the next to follow suit. If every state requires full disclosure via tax returns in order to get on the ballot, then America is on the way to holding candidates accountable.
Hell Yes! We all know there is a clear reason the orange orangutan won't release his taxes. The idiot, never would not be in the White House if this was a requirement. Let's learn from our mistakes and fix this so it will never happen again.
This should've been done years ago, but then again we never had a candidate refuse to submit her/his returns. Why our lawmakers allowed the Liar in Chief to refuse to submit his is beyond me. Only guilty/liars have something to hid.
Wow! This makes so much sense ! If you want to serve in public office anywhere, this should be the norm. I agree with Timnyc, "Well I think we learned this lesson.We should expect and require all candidates as well as Congressional appointments to clear a full background and financial vetting PRIOR to any appointment. This is standard practice for all My Law Enforcement Jobs as well as my wife's Federal Job . No one should be appointed or hired without this check ." Should you feel squeamish about compliance, then you are not qualified to serve. A mental health exam and clearance wouldn't be a bad idea either, in the wake of the current office holder of the presidency.